Music

(Not) My Superman

Coming to terms with loving Eminem.

Collage by Ruby Aitken.

Collage by Ruby A.

Feminist women love Eminem (chigga chigga chigga)
“Slim Shady, I’m sick of him, look at him
Walkin’ around grabbin’ his you-know-what
Flippin’ the you-know-who”
“Yeah, but he’s so cute though.”

—Eminem, “The Real Slim Shady”

I remember the first time I listened to Eminem’s song “Kim.” I was 15, alone in my bedroom, doors closed, headphones on. In high school I listened almost exclusively to hip-hop, and I hadn’t been particularly impressed with Eminem’s first album, which had come out a year earlier. Plus, I thought his bleached hair looked stupid. But even a self-involved teenager like me couldn’t help noticing how feminists and conservatives alike were freaking out over his lyrics, especially the lyrics for that song “Kim,” that one where he kidnaps and murders his then-wife. Anyone who could unite polar opposites in mutual outrage was worth a listen. So I stole “Kim” off of Napster and I listened as Eminem (aka Marshall Mathers) scream-rapped obscenities and threats at his partner, whose throat he slits (“Bleed, bitch, bleed!”) and whose body he stuffs into the trunk of his car, the whole story gleefully interspersed with tender baby talk addressed to the couple’s daughter, Hailie. It was a love song, too, I slowly realized: “I swear to god I hate you / Oh my god I love you,” he wailed. Another long verse and a few choruses later, I felt unsettled and repulsed. I didn’t talk for probably an hour.

“Kim” wasn’t the cleverest song in Eminem’s catalog. It wasn’t as witty as “Guilty Conscience” or as meta as “Without Me” (“I’ve created a monster / ’Cause nobody wants to see Marshall no more / They want Shady, I’m chopped liver”) nor as chock-full of dizzyingly virtuosic multisyllabic rhymes as “The Way I Am” (“Sometimes I just feel like my father / I hate to be bothered / With all of this nonsense, it’s constant”). But “Kim” was the song that started my obsession with Eminem. For the next few years, I spent many solo hours enveloped in his rage against women and gay people and pretty much everyone. (Bumping to his music in a group felt grotesque; I didn’t want to know which of my guy friends were genuinely cheering him on.)

Any woman who loves hip-hop—actually, make that all popular culture—will find herself constantly redrawing and policing the boundaries of her tolerance, doing daily weigh-ins of her own hypocrisy. In high school I was into NWA and Tupac, and even gentler rappers like Outkast and Brand Nubian, despite their misogyny. I wished some of my favorite songs could be purged of the needless name-calling—Biggie and Method Man’s “The What,” for instance, would be no worse for wear without the line “Bitches, I like ’em brainless.” I didn’t overlook the bigotry in those songs; I tolerated it. With Eminem, it was the misogyny itself that got under my skin; he made it seem so scary and depraved, all that ugliness and rage and shame and violent self-hatred that lurked beneath milder expressions of misogyny and homophobia. Offhanded, anonymous sexism was harder to get outraged about, harder to explain to my guy friends. “Don’t take it so seriously!” I could hear them saying. “Money, cash, hoes! Cristal, afterparties, road head!”

Eminem didn’t have sleazy, objectifying party songs; he had furious, murderous meltdowns. His was not a blithe misogyny. “Kim,” was dark, violent, out of control; but the “Kim” in the song is not a prop—she’s a demon. A demon has power. Not that acting out the kidnapping and murder of your domestic partner is some awesome feminist statement. And, duh, hating women is bullshit all around. But while the song pissed me off and provoked me, it never objectified or excluded me. Eminem is capable of conveying great humor and joy in his music (see “The Real Slim Shady,” “My Name Is”), but he didn’t write “Kim” to make anyone laugh. He did it to show us what a profoundly fucked-up human he was. He wasn’t bragging—he was confessing. He was daring us to hate him when Jay-Z and Puffy and Snoop were begging us to love them.

“Kim” wasn’t escapist or aspirational; it was personal. It threw the realities of domestic violence in my face, which were all the more terrifying because I knew the feelings in the song were culled from life. Unlike those ebullient songs marred by references to “big-booty skanks,” Eminem’s eloquent vitriol always made me feel galvanized, if only because it made me feel, made me rail against him and the sexist world around me even as I recognized the allure of both. I felt like I had more power in this private love-hate relationship with a rapper than I did dancing to something that condescendingly reduced me to something sexy and dumb (or, maybe worse: fed me empty platitudes about all the Strong Women out there). If Eminem became wildly popular not in spite of but because of his misogyny, as some critics feared, it says more about us than it does about him.

In 2001, the year after The Marshall Mathers LP came out, Dr. Dre came out with his comeback album, 2001. A few months later, Eminem’s third album, The Eminem Show, was released. I was 17, and I remember listening to Dre and Em in tandem, loving the latter more than ever while feeling profoundly let down by the former. One track on 2001 made me angrier than any Eminem murder fantasy ever had: Called “Explosive,” it had an infectious, multipurpose beat—it was a vacation song, a weed-smoking song, a walk-to-class song. Yet there was so much gratuitous contempt for women in this otherwise harmless party track:

Fuck a bitch; don’t tease, bitch, striptease, bitch
Eat a bowl of these, bitch, gobble the dick
Hoes forgot to eat a dick can shut the fuck up
Gobble and swallow a nut up, shut up and get my cash
Backhanded, pimp-slapped backwards and left stranded
Just pop ya collar, pimp convention hoes for a dollar

Yikes. I hated Dre for reeling me in and then promptly disinviting me from the party. Dre (and his guest star, Kurupt) weren’t egging me on with their throwaway bitches and hos. They were dismissing me altogether.

The Eminem Show, meanwhile, needled the listener for a response. Here was a fully formed character floored by the resonance of his own self-proclaimed white-trashiness, at once smirking and throwing a hissy fit as he cruelly taunted us, his most devoted fans. By this time Eminem was both carefully orchestrating his image and becoming entirely unhinged, and it showed on this album, which was layered with self-referential anxiety. In “Superman,” he mercilessly derided Mariah Carey, fantasized about slapping her till she couldn’t stand and putting handprints (not the good kind) all across her. He made me hate him, but he also managed to make me complicit in reducing my own childhood idol to a pathetic social climber. And then he warned me, on the eve of my high school graduation, months away from 8 Mile, his good-boy feature film debut:

You want what you can’t have
Ooh girl, that’s too damn bad
Don’t touch what you can’t grab
End up with two backhands

It was moments like this when the clever wordsmith I loved snubbed me—reminded me not to try to know him, not to trust him, not to defend him too hard. I played that track over and over: “I can’t be your Superman, your Superman, your Superman.”

Eminem has a keen sense of irony, but he’s no Matthew Weiner; he’s not trying to expose misogyny by showing us how it works. And sometimes his sexism is just run-of-the-mill posturing, part and parcel of his aggro–“trailer trash” persona. And when his vulnerability makes an appearance, it’s enjoyed only by the worthiest of women—his daughter. The devolution of “Hailie’s Song” into a screed against Kim is typical Madonna–whore stuff, no different from Tupac throwing “Keep Ya Head Up,” his ode to black womanhood, on the same album as the casually sexist “I Get Around.” I’m sure Eminem wasn’t aware that his misogyny was radicalizing me or anyone else.

Realtalk, I didn’t understand that either back then. I loved Eminem in a straightforward, zero-subtext way. I loved him because he was a “bad boy.” My mother, the rock critic Ellen Willis, once wrote that she chose “love over sexual-political common sense” when it came to the often sexist songs of rock & roll musicians. In life and relationships, that’s a terrible idea. In pop culture, it’s allowed.

My love for Eminem mimicked an abusive relationship, but with none of the horrible consequences. I fantasized about changing him and schooling him, about arguing with him and even hate-fucking him. By loving him I could safely play with the idea of being lured in and terrified by a charismatic, abusive tough guy while remaining unharmed, free to come and go as I pleased. His music allowed me to flirt with danger and then be revolted by it, to feel empathy for this put-upon working-class hero and then have that sympathy smashed to pieces. I worked through the whole cycle of attraction, rationalization, apology, fear, and revulsion in my head, which kind of inoculated me against getting involved with that kind of guy in real life.

I lost interest in Eminem shortly after 8 Mile. But a few years ago, my ears perked up when anti-Eminem feminists wrung their hands anew with the release of “Love the Way You Lie.” Its chorus, chillingly, is sung by Rihanna, recorded a year after photos of her bruised and bloody face surfaced on the internet; its video depicts Megan Fox and Dominic Monaghan engaging in an electric hybrid of fighting and foreplay in a house that’s in the process of burning to the ground.

This track was about Kim, too, but this time Eminem’s anger was directed only at himself. “I feel so ashamed I snapped,” he confessed. “I laid hands on her, I’ll never stoop so low again.” It’s the closest he had ever come to apologizing for the verbal and physical pain he’d inflicted on Kim over the years, but it wasn’t a tidy apology. He blamed it all on passion: “High off love, drunk from my hate…she fuckin’ hates me but I love it.” This chemistry was in next-level amour fou territory, the kind both abusers and victims routinely invoke to excuse domestic violence. I wasn’t mad at it. This song wasn’t a relationship manual; it was an exposition of raw, human messiness.

Against a backdrop that’s all elbows and bruises and sweat and flames, Eminem wheedles in the video: “I’m Superman with the wind at his back, she’s Lois Lane.” Chills crawled down my arms, even as his defeated refrain to Mariah from a decade ago rang loudly in my ears. I knew it was a lie, but I loved it. ♦

A version of this essay originally appeared in the zine anthology It’s Complicated.

Nona Willis Aronowitz is a writer, an editor, the author of Girldrive, and a cofounder of Tomorrow magazine. She still has “Love the Way You Lie” on her workout playlist.

17 Comments

  • LittleMissE August 7th, 2013 4:26 PM

    This essay is astoundingly well-written and sums up beautifully my feelings for Eminem and his music, in a way I’ve never been able to. Thank you.

  • seemoo August 7th, 2013 5:05 PM

    This is amazing, so different from what I expected,

  • Sharon August 7th, 2013 5:06 PM

    I’v wanted to see something like this for a long time. I love Eminem. I fucking hate Eminem.

  • Sophie ❤ August 7th, 2013 5:21 PM

    Why, Rookie, does it always happen that you express my exact feelings about something at the exactly right time? I was just thinking about Eminem, and I was actually listening to one of Eminem’s albums while I was reading this. The words sum everything up perfectly!

    http://theneonpapaya.com

  • Hecubot August 7th, 2013 5:48 PM

    Fantastic essay about a complex issue in music fandom.

    I remember Ellen Willis (one of the greatest rock music critics ever) having some of the same issues with Mick Jagger.

  • llamalina August 7th, 2013 6:01 PM

    This is brilliant. Exactly how I feel about Eminem and Tyler, the Creator. Fuck them. But I also adore them.

  • Tyknos93 August 7th, 2013 8:31 PM

    Here for this!

    I can’t quite wrap my head around all of it, but Rap and Hip-Hop speaks to me in a way other music just can’t.

    That RAW energy and passion and vitriol. Sometimes I just want to hear that more than anything else. I often feel I’m being irresponsible though. Like what if my kid brothers think it’s okay to talk about/ treat women the way they are portrayed in Hip Hop culture (and most other forms of media for that matter).

    I know what I listen to doesn’t make me any less of a good person, but it just seems like it’s at odds with some of my beliefs.

    Can’t tell you how long I’ve been waiting for this article. I even made a less than eloquent post about it a while ago (lol) http://blazoningpens.blogspot.com/2012/06/innocent-pleasures.html

  • luanda jabur August 7th, 2013 9:24 PM

    this is going to sound weird, but as long as i heard the lyrics to every song eminem has about kim, i never saw it as sexism, cause i think i always saw her as a person that made him angry and not like he was offended to the women gender. i love his love for hailie, i love him till today, even i dont listen to him anymore… i think it has so much to do with teenagers cause we feel with so much intensity that we can resemble without taking it too serious, cause it’s not, its like the message in stan: this is what i say, think sometimes, not what i do.

  • Mags August 7th, 2013 11:57 PM

    Man, the Marshall Mathers LP was my favorite for the longest time. It was like a form of therapy to listen to someone so angry actually expressing his anger. I still know all the lyrics to The Way I Am — that was my favorite song, but I loved all of them.

    I liked some of his later work, but not as much as the MM album.

    Lately, though, I don’t care for his music at all, and I’m tired of his schtick. The whole making-fun-of-every-celeb out there is just getting old. Like, I already know who he’s going to pick on before the song even comes out. And it’s so juvenile. Sure, he has more serious songs, but I don’t think they negate his sexist ones.

    And as much as I don’t care for Christina Aguilera, the fact that he slut-shamed her in “The Real Slim Shady” (and wasn’t she a teenager when that song came out?) just doesn’t sit well with him.

    I think people give him WAY too much credit. He’s not some sort of musical genius or anything.

  • milkcrystals August 8th, 2013 3:56 AM

    Other commenters said it but I’ll repeat it, this is such a perfect articulation of my feelings towards Eminem. I listened to Eminem non stop when I was a depressed fifteen year old girl to the point where he remains my #1 top artist on last.fm.

    Kim was one of my favorite songs- and oh god I’m going to sound pathetic but there was a time when I loved it because I would listen to it pretending he was shouting at me, because I ~hated myself so much and wanted to hear everything I was thinking out loud.

    Despite this, Eminem helped me through so much. I still listen to so many of his songs when I need to. I do believe that at the his music encouraged how down I was feeling, but I relate to way too many of his lyrics to ever stop.

    BTW- Relapse was A+++ one of his most solid albums, Deja Vu, Insane and My Mom are some of my all time favorite songs of any artist. Deja Vu has the ability to bring me to tears, any day.

  • EmmaAmerica August 8th, 2013 7:50 AM

    this is actually the definition of brilliance.

  • wcw August 9th, 2013 7:57 PM

    I agree with this article 100%. But I also think Eminem is one of the most talented rappers there is (he’s definitely in my top 2), and would even argue one of the most talented artists of our generation. He is just so good and no one can touch him – that’s part of why I loved him. Remember the Benzino diss – hilarious. Another thing that the author touched on was that he showed emotions – anger, sadness, pain, silliness, happiness – and to be honest, most male rappers (let alone a lot of men in general) don’t do that. He was real, and authenticity is something our age group highly values. Anyway, we can sit here all day and rationalize why we love this guy, but I think all we have to do is play “Stan” and there’s your answer.

  • monalisa August 10th, 2013 5:47 AM

    this was extremely beautifully written

  • reginageorge August 10th, 2013 7:29 AM

    I never liked Eminem and I don’t think I ever will. His attention-grabbing stunts are exactly the same thing female celebrities get crap for every single day and they come across as really juvenile. Even if it’s a persona it’s still a grating one. I don’t think it’s ever been thought-provoking for me at all – just rude and some meaningless noise about hurting women.

    I wouldn’t say that this is better because it’s more blatant and easier to explain than more veiled sexism. I also wouldn’t say that a song murdering his wife or slapping Mariah is not objectification – that is exactly what it is, the notion that men should have some kind of say over women’s bodies and can use them or dispose of them as they see fit. It’s the sense of entitlement that leads men to think it’s cool to write songs about injuring their significant others. Objectification doesn’t have to be openly sexual, it can have sexual undertones or be more violence based, in my opinion.

    As an aside, having Ellen Willis as your mother must be just about the coolest thing thing ever. Or at the very least the coolest thing I’ve heard this week.

  • Fiona Pelz August 10th, 2013 1:23 PM

    i’ve been looking for something that articulated my feelings about eminem as well as this did.

  • abby111039 August 19th, 2013 10:15 PM

    This is article is just outstanding. It’s not often I read something that makes my heart accelerate a bit or makes me scream in my head “Holy shit this is so true I could’ve written it myself”. I. Love. It.