Books + Comics

Thrills & Chills

Whodunits, true crime, and other books that are ~shrouded in mystery~.

9780307278449The Bluest Eye
Toni Morrison
1970, Holt, Rinehart and Winston

Oh my god, The Bluest Eye. Do you know those books that, for whatever reason, you know are probably good but you pass over them time and time again without knowing why? For a while, that was my relationship with this novel. WHAT A WASTE OF TIME THAT WAS, because when I finally read it, it rocketed to the top of my Best Favorites list immediately. It’s the story of a young black girl named Pecola and her relationships with race, beauty, and identity, and it takes a hard look at the way those things can intersect. It’s so marvelously written that I almost can’t stand it. It’s got pain and beauty and the kind of descriptive writing that will make you wince and swoon and think. The Bluest Eye is full of everything, so don’t make the mistake that I did and sleep on it. —Amy Rose

tumblr_m631ikcTQN1rsbp8vo1_1280Sputnik Sweetheart
Haruki Murakami
1999, Kodansha

This book was my introduction to Haruki Murakami, who quickly became one of my favorite authors. He weaves mystery and romance through all of his novels, but Sputnik Sweetheart is especially haunting, and will leave you with many lingering questions. Told from the point of view of “K,” a young schoolteacher, the story focuses on Sumire, a chain-smoking loner and aspiring writer. K is in love with Sumire, but she doesn’t care for him. One day she meets Miu, a sophisticated businesswoman who is almost twice Sumire’s age. Sumire begins to work for Miu, and they fall in love. While the women are vacationing in Greece, Sumire suddenly disappears into thin air. And so begins K’s search for her, which will come to involve cats, letters, parallel universes, ferris wheels and more. It’s an amazing book and I’m still not sure I’ve solved all its mysteries. —Hazel

130460-pic_1In the Woods
Tana French
2007, Viking Adult

I know people who routinely fall in love with writers and then read all of their books back to back, gobbling entire careers whole. I’ve almost never done that, because I like to bounce around—fiction to nonfiction, mystery to comedy. But last fall I feel deep, deep into a Tana French groove, reading all four of the books in her Dublin Murder Squad series, each of which takes a minor character from the previous novel and makes him or her the star. I started with In the Woods, the first book in the series, but you don’t have to: each one is its own gritty, well-plotted story about cops in Dublin, Ireland. French’s writing is as clear as a bell, and her plots twist in unexpected ways. I’m counting the days until the next book is released, reportedly sometime in 2014. —Emma

And_Then_There_Were_None_jpg_232x500_q95Everything by Agatha Christie
It’s not just Tana French, though—I love all kinds of mystery novels (lately I’ve been devouring books by Kate Atkinson as well). The godmother of them all, though, is undoubtedly Agatha Christie. I started to read her stuff soon after I outgrew Christopher Pike and Lois Lowry, and lucky for me and other mystery lovers over the past 90-some years, Christie was massively prolific. Between 1920 and 1976, she wrote 66 novels and 150 short stories. Her two main detectives–the suave Hercule Poirot and the somewhat pushy old lady Miss Marple–were among my closest friends. Reading an Agatha Christie novel, whether it’s Murder on the Orient Express or And Then There Were None, is still 10 times more satisfying to me than watching an episode of Law & Order. One of my favorite Christie novels is The Murder of Roger Ackroyd, the first novel I ever read with an unreliable narrator, which I reviewed here. Reading it opened my eyes to a world of previously unimaginable ideas of what a book could do or be. Agatha was by no means perfect: her pre–World War II descriptions of Jewish characters can be hard to stomach today, and her writing is sometimes less than graceful. But if you’re looking for a good book about a murder and some excellent travel reportage from the window of a moving train, you really can’t do better. Take an entire stack with you the next time you go on vacation and astonish yourself with your speed-reading. —Emma

Dave Cullen
2009, Twelve

Last May I went to Paris, a city I had been wanting to visit my whole life. I don’t mean to be all “girl who goes abroad and comes back a ~changed person~,” BUT I LEARNED SO MUCH, Y’ALL. One of the biggest lessons among many: DO NOT BRING COLUMBINE BY DAVE CULLEN WITH YOU TO THE CITY OF YOUR DREAMS. It’s far too consumptive and unputdownable, and you will be unhappily torn between it and all the sights you have to see. I actually almost missed out on major, rare experiences because I wanted so badly just to continue reading this book. Columbine is singular and beautiful, horrible and humanizing. It is also the most insightful and dedicated piece of reporting I have ever read. The book recounts the truest possible version of the story of the murders at Columbine High School in 1999. It also reveals that almost every single narrative we previously knew from the media’s coverage of the atrocity was in some way incorrect. It is a fucking AMAZING, exhaustively researched book. By the end, my empathy had been stretched to at least two sizes bigger than before. Just trust me on this one: if Columbine made me reluctant to leave my hotel room in goddamned PARIS, it’s got to be a pretty excellent read, right? Right. —Amy Rose

63a18cc85a9d0ef507999d4ec0d3ff55Gone Girl
Gillian Flynn
2012, Crown Publishing Group

I can’t remember the last time a book chilled me the way this one did. Nick comes home one day to find his wife, Amy, is missing. He calls the police and organizes a search party, but despite his efforts he remains the prime suspect. The narrative switches between Nick’s point of view and Amy’s diary entries in the days, months, and years before her disappearance. Even when you’re right in the heads of these characters, you’re still never certain whom to believe, or what’s not being revealed. Don’t start reading it if you have anything important to do in the next 12 hours. —Anna

womaninwhiteThe Woman in White
Wilkie Collins
1859–1860, All the Year Round

There is so much about the Victorian novel that usually turns me off: Women with no agency! Martyrdom as salvation! Everyone just sitting in one room doing embroidery! Since The Woman in White is from that era, I was hesitant to give the book a chance after a friend recommended it, but I took a look and was immediately sucked into the story about a young artist, Walter, who moves to London to teach a young woman, Laura Fairlie, how to paint. On his way, he encounters a woman dressed in white, running away from…something, or someone. Immediate mystery! We will not know who she is or why she is running for a while, but the story of Walter, the Fairlie house, graveyards, ghosts, terrible spouses, badass broads, family mystery, love, revenge, and spooky uncles is absolutely worth the read. If you like curling up in a corner with a cup of tea on a cold night, this is the book for you. —Danielle

1144759_37928136_trimmedBecause They Wanted To
Mary Gaitskill
1998, Simon & Schuster

Proceed with caution when reading this book. Mary Gaitskill’s characters tend to be horrible, awful people, their awfulness revealed so slowly that you don’t fully grasp it are until you empathize with and kinda-sorta like them. Gaitskill’s sentences are beautifully set traps that pull you in with their gorgeousness and then knock you on your ass when all their darkness starts to set in. So, um, ENJOY! —Amy Rose

Uses-For-Boys-Erica-Lorraine-Scheidt-Book-CoverUses for Boys
Erica Lorraine Scheidt
2013, St. Martin’s Griffin

Anna remembers a time when her mother recounted happy, tell-me-again stories about how she’d been all alone, but then she had Anna, and everything was perfect, just the two of them. But then her mother got boyfriends and husbands and facelifts and Anna ends up mostly by herself in a big empty house. She starts to fill the void with boys, not really seeing the difference between sex and love, even though she definitely hears people whispering about her. While thrift-shopping in her suburban Oregon town, Anna meets a girl named Toy, who becomes her first friend, but who seems to have her own secrets that she keeps from Anna. Everything Anna is dealing with is very real, but the story is told in this dreamy, lyrical way that fans of Francesca Lia Block will love; and I think it will help anyone who reads it unravel some of the mysteries they carry in their hearts. —Stephanie

AWQ1_cover_finalWho Could That Be at This Hour?
Lemony Snicket
2012, Little, Brown

It’s not necessary to know the plots of the books in Lemony Snicket’s series A Series of Unfortunate Events to understand this prequel, but they do serve as a great introduction to Snicket’s hilarious and absurdly cryptic style. This is the first book in a new series, All the Wrong Questions, that chronicles the adventures of a preteen, fictionalized version of Snicket during his time spent working for a mysterious organization. If you think this book is going to answer any of the questions raised by ASOUE, you are going to drive yourself mad. There are more questions raised, more surreal locations, more bizarre characters with niche interests and ambiguous motivations, than ever before, and more things are obscured than are revealed. Just go along for the ride. —Anna

in-the-last-analysisIn the Last Analysis
Amanda Cross
1964, Avon; 2001, Fawcett

You’ll run into the occasional critic on the internet who will call this tiny paperback—or its hero, Kate Fansler, a feminist English professor/amateur sleuth—“pretentious.” They’re not totally wrong: The book’s first 20 words alone manage to squeeze in not only a reference to Sigmund Freud, but also a mention of the “freudful errors” in James Joyce’s Finnegans Wake. YIKES. But if you can stop yourself from throwing the book at the wall at that point, it can be pretty fun to read—especially if you’re into English lit. After one of Fansler’s students turns up dead during a trip to the shrink (I know, I know), literary allusions help the professor solve the case. And, as a single lady with tenure in the 1960s, a time when that was considered freakish, she’s pretty determined to solve it without the help of the cops or other meddling men. Aside from the story, which has plenty of funny/campy moments that help lighten things up, the coolest thing about this book—and the others that follow it in the Kate Fansler series—may be its author. Amanda Cross was eventually revealed to be the pen name of Carolyn Heilbrun, a feminist scholar and Columbia University English professor who had been writing mysteries in secret. —Lena Singer

my_year_of_meatsMy Year of Meats
Ruth L. Ozeki
1998, Viking Press

This is a totally engrossing novel in so many different ways. Investigative journalism! Environmental food politics! Race theory! Love stories! Every one of those things is addressed in a curious, exploratory, openminded way in this book, and it fucking rules. If you’re into epistolary narratives (stories that are told, at least in part, through letters and emails and such), as I very much am, you will especially love this probing, cross-cultural look at meat consumption. I was completely transfixed by it, and I’m not even a vegetarian or anything. —Amy Rose

Beautiful frontcover 3.09.previewBeautiful
Amy Reed
2010, Simon Pulse

Cassie starts seventh grade as the new girl, and she uses her family’s move to suburban Seattle as a chance to totally transform herself and become “beautiful”—the kind of girl who is wanted by the ninth grade skater boys and is best friends with Alex, a tough girl Cassie describes as “not even close to pretty, but…bigger than pretty.” You can see why Cassie is enthralled by Alex and her dangerous world of doing drugs and having sex under freeway overpasses, and you follow her as she spirals out of control. And at the end you finally figure out what makes these girls who they are. It’s not a beautiful story, it’s something bigger. —Stephanie ♦


  • Kylie Flynn March 14th, 2013 11:40 PM

    ‘Beautiful’ is an amazing book, although it’s not the kind of book that critics would rave over or anything, i still loved it. I always judge the quality of a book or movie over whether it left you feeling affected at the end…and this one definitely does!!!!!:)

  • eremiomania March 14th, 2013 11:52 PM

    So much love for this list of books. I can’t wait to read Columbine because of my weird addiction to reading about mass murders.

  • missblack March 15th, 2013 12:14 AM

    can I just say how much I love Agatha Christie?? I first started reading her books when I was like ten-ish and man I fell HARD.
    And did anyone else watch the show on PBS that said that the way her books are written actually hypnotizes you so that you become completely engrossed and lose track of time/what’s going on around you? I totally believe it.


  • Jessica Vixenelle March 15th, 2013 12:18 AM

    Even though it’s not a ‘whodunit’ or totally mysterious, THE SECRET HISTORY by Donna Tartt is full of crime and weirdo college kids and Greek philosophy, oh my gosh, you kids should read it!

  • spudzine March 15th, 2013 1:00 AM

    OHMAGOD when I saw ‘Beautiful’ as a suggested read I was utterly shocked- in a good way. It was one of those books that I thought only I had read, because no one else around me seems to have read it. However, Rookie proved otherwise!
    It’s a really great book that seems to be written in a poetic fashion about a girl whose life seems to spiral into chaos.

  • takebackyourpower March 15th, 2013 2:37 AM


  • sugarmilz March 15th, 2013 3:24 AM

    I actually really want to read Columbine and I don’t know why because it’s a mass murder, but it sounds so good! In the woods and gone girl look awesome too

  • anyone March 15th, 2013 6:40 AM

    I have a serious book-addiction… And of course the book posts are my absolute FAVORITE ones. I wait the whole month for them just so I can feed my obsession with books… GOD…
    (But through Rookie I discovered some awesome books such as “The Passage” and – of course – “Weetzie Bat”. So I know, I can count on your book-taste)

  • alisatimi March 15th, 2013 7:35 AM

    Oh my gosh I’m so happy you included The Woman in White! Wilkie Collins is my favorite mystery writer apart from Arthur Conan Doyle… Sherlock Holmes should definitely be on this list as well.

  • GabbyCat March 15th, 2013 10:16 AM

    I’m so excited for Who Could That Be At This Hour? because it seems similar to A Series of Unfortunate Events, which defined my childhood. Speaking of books that are incredibly awesome, is there ever going to be another Rookie Yearbook?

  • wallflower152 March 15th, 2013 10:53 AM

    If you’re a fan of Dexter the tv show then read the books. It’s like an alternate reality of the tv show. Only the first book and season one are alike. After that the stories go their separate ways. So awesome. And I want to read some Agatha Christie!

  • lizzyheinie March 15th, 2013 2:05 PM

    Gone Girl has been checked out/reserved at my library EVER SINCE IT CAME OUT and no matter what I do I cannot get my hands on it and it’s making me REALLY UPSET OKAY

  • e graham March 15th, 2013 2:28 PM

    if you like wilkie collins, check out “drood” by dan simmons. it’s really really fun and involves charles dickens, subterranean london, egyptian mysticism, hypnotism, madness and about a million other awesome things.

  • HollinsCollins March 15th, 2013 2:48 PM

    Eeee I love Agatha Christi! Even though I’ve only read And Then There Were None.
    And I read most of Gone Girl (EVERYONE WAS SO MEAN…I just needed to read some Meg Cabot), and it was perty good.

  • Maddy March 15th, 2013 5:18 PM

    Holy moly!!! I came on here planning to comment about how you guys SHOULD ALL READ In the Woods and boy, was I surprised! My mom’s family is full of voracious readers and we cycle stacks of book through each household. I read “In the Woods” and it was so good. It might be my favorite book. I think about it quite often and it really moved me. I took the book out of rotation and hid it in the back of a closet so my family wouldn’t find it and read it and know something about me. God, I cried so hard in that book. I also read Columbine (and cried). I had only really heard about the incident but after reading the book, I learned the complex events and motivations behind it. Also, yes to Agatha Christie, always yes. She is best read in the summer (start with “Murder on the Orient Express”, then “Witness for the Prosecution” then “The Murder of Roger Ackroyd”)

    <3 you guys (good mood, even though I didn't get a national Scholastic. any of you guys enter?)

  • EveyMarrie March 15th, 2013 6:20 PM

    I definitely recommend ‘As Simple As Snow’ as a good mystery read. Goth girl and plain boy start a friendship, become a couple, and soon enough the girl disappears. She leaves behind her books of obituaries she wrote for EVERY SINGLE PERSON in town. The real mystery is not much where she went, but why? And what does the boy do with himself afterward?

    • rhymeswithorange March 15th, 2013 6:57 PM

      yes, great book!!

  • AnaRuiz March 15th, 2013 6:49 PM

    Remember that there is a Rookie group where we comment on several different books mentioned here on Rookie!! The link is:

  • Whatsername March 15th, 2013 6:57 PM

    Love this post. I went through a huuuuge Agatha Christie phase last year.

  • Hunter March 15th, 2013 8:26 PM

    “Columbine” by Dave Cullen is actually wildly and laughably inaccurate.

    • hanalady March 17th, 2013 10:33 PM

      say more

      • Rae0320 March 22nd, 2013 8:35 AM

        I haven’t read Columbine so don’t really think I’m qualified to comment BUT when I was looking at (maybe buying) this on Amazon, Randy Brown’s comments (father of Brooks Brown, the boy who Eric told to go home the day of the shooting) specifically disputes Cullen’s book for a few reasons, mainly: defining Eric as a psychopath, disregarding bullying as a possible catalyst (instead inferring that Eric was evil/had no empathy at all), speculating ‘thoughts’ of the two boys (including moments of regret in the library) and more.

        People have kind of torn Randy to shreds though, assuming that a high profile reporter must know all the facts, even if he wasn’t there. I don’t think it really matters who is right, because it’s all speculation, and it all comes down to the same thing in the end. But it does make me real sad that Randy was verbally attacked, because he seems like an articulate, nice guy who is trying to advocate anti-bullying and ensure the two boys (especially Eric) aren’t just dismissed as crazy. Of course, everyone can make up their own mind (and like I said, I haven’t read the book, so I don’t know the prominence or context of the problems that Randy perceives within it)

        Read the comments here:

        If that doesn’t work, just find Columbine on and look for 1 star reviews, and the one written by Randy.

  • Miss Erin March 15th, 2013 9:11 PM

    I agree COLUMBINE is so completely gripping. Just as good as IN COLD BLOOD, imho.

  • Ella March 15th, 2013 11:04 PM

    I’m dying to read Haruki Mukamari! (hope i spelled his name right) The only problem is, where do I start?

    • littleredradio March 16th, 2013 10:15 AM

      Do read Sputnik Sweetheart!! It’s really good.
      First book I read by Murakami was Norwegian Wood which I also enjoyed. I really liked 1Q84 too (which is a series of three books), very mysterious and thrilling.

  • hellorose March 16th, 2013 8:47 AM

    Amy Rose –
    If you like epistolary novels I recommend ‘Ella Minnow Pea’ by Mark Dunn. It follows the correspondence of a young woman living on a fictional island where the inhabitants devote themselves to the teachings of Nevin Nollop, inventor of the pangram ‘the quick brown fox jumped over the lazy dog’. When letters begin to fall from the statue of Nollop in the town square, the council decide that the inhabitants of the island can no longer use those letters in speech or writing. As more letters fall, the island descends into chaos.

  • mwong1025 March 16th, 2013 8:59 AM

    I love “Who Could It Be At This Hour?” so much! Can’t wait for the sequel so Lemony Snicket/Daniel Handler can drive us completely mad with even more question..

  • littleredradio March 16th, 2013 10:16 AM

    Gone Girl DROVE ME CRAZY, good god. That book is amazing.

    I always love Rookie’s recommendations.

  • TessaTheTeenageWitch March 16th, 2013 10:08 PM

    Agatha Christie kinda changed my reading life. I first read ‘Murder in the Library’ when I was 11 when my family was on holidays in Wales and the only book store we could find was a tiny second-hand one, and it really kick-started my obsession with mystery and crime. I adore Miss Marple and I am eternally grateful for the introduction to whodunits that A.C provided me!

    All of these titles are now on my never-ending ‘to read’ list! Thanks guys!

  • Shona McGarry March 23rd, 2013 2:39 PM

    Great to see some Agatha Christie love! My friend and I put on a production of And Then There Were None in college this year; it’s been one of my favourites of hers for years. Crooked House is also good for spooks, as is By The Pricking Of My Thumbs. Love it. Old-fashioned English country things get me every time anyway!